The Public Editor

Painting a Clear and Full Picture Through Opinion and the News

November 9, 2009 - 4:33am
By Rob Tricchinelli

The Sun has spilled much ink on the Student Assembly’s decision to reduce Cornell Cinema’s part of the Student Activity Fee and the subsequent affirmation of that decision on appeal. The issue has ruffled feathers, and I want to give readers my idea of how it all played out.

The strongest aspect of the coverage is that after reporting the story, The Sun’s pages served as a forum for people on both sides of the issue to be heard. The weakest, however, is that the news coverage — and even some of The Sun’s own editorial product — was somewhat underreported, missing important facts that could have provided better context.

The Nature of the Dialogue Between Writers and Readers

October 26, 2009 - 4:40am
By Rob Tricchinelli

The relationship between The Sun and its readers should be a two-way street. The paper’s coverage, obviously, is a gateway through which the campus community can stay informed. But the paper is ultimately beholden to its readers, and reader feedback must be one element to guide The Sun’s decision-makers in their overall vision for the paper.

Correcting News When Facts Prove Dubious

September 28, 2009 - 11:00pm
By Rob Tricchinelli

A front-page, above-the-fold story in the Sep. 21 issue of The Sun, “Undergrads May Teach FWS to Reduce Cost,” caused some distress; it turned out to be wrong. When a front-page story is not correct, a comprehensive look is worth the effort. A few factors were at play here, and The Sun has since taken steps to do right by its sources and its readers.

Taken at its face, the story seemed like a real scoop. With a foundering endowment and a call for spending cuts, departments across Cornell are making difficult decisions on a tighter budget; hypothetically, having undergraduates teach First-Year Writing Seminars might help reduce costs. It might also alleviate problems associated with a growing undergraduate population but a declining number of graduate students.

Clarity on Profanity

September 14, 2009 - 2:00am
By Rob Tricchinelli

Opening to the opinion pages of The Sun, a reader can sometimes spot profanity. This paper has no official policy on whether and when such words are acceptable, preferring instead to handle each individual case on its own. I think this is another area in the editorial process that can improve. I have encouraged some Sun editors to formulate more concrete — but not exhaustive — guidelines, and I hope this column can serve as a way to get the conversation going on what those guidelines should be.