Cornell Caps Loans for Those in Need
January 31, 2008 - 1:00amIt may be hard to enjoy the college experience knowing that tuition alone requires $34,600 a year, but the outlook for debt-ridden students may improve today with Cornell’s announcement of its new financial aid initiative. By the 2009-2010 academic year, students whose families make less than $75,000 a year will receive grants in place of the traditional need-based loans, while those from families with incomes between $75,000 and $120,000 will see their loans capped at $3,000 a year.
Meanwhile, for the 2008-2009 transition period, the University will replace loans for students with family incomes under $60,000 and cap loans at $3,000 for those with household incomes between $60,000 and $120,000.
According to Provost Biddy Martin, the average Cornell student graduates with about $23,000 in loans.
“Essentially we’ve been thinking about doing this for a long time and the primary reason is because we think that’s too much debt,” she said. According to Martin, these financial aid problems have also long been on President David Skorton’s mind.
“I want to remind you that I’m a first-generation college student from a family that couldn’t afford to do much,” Skorton said. “It took me 20 years to pay my loans off. And for that reason, I have a personal commitment to see us do better in this regard.”
Hopes are therefore high for more students from lower-income backgrounds to come to Cornell, according to Deputy Provost David Harris. Before the change, a student whose family made $50,000 would have had about $22,000 in loans upon graduation. Under the new policy, the student would graduate loan-free.
“The hope is that because of the increased information and transparency that appears on our financial aid website, students who previously would have said, ‘I can’t afford Cornell; I’m not even applying,’ will now say, ‘Oh, look at the example of [the student with a family income of] $50,000. Hey this is something I can imagine doing,’” Harris said. “So that would increase the number of people from lower socioeconomic categories that would apply to Cornell.”
According to Martin, this goal represents Cornell’s traditional commitment to economic diversity.
“Cornell is already more economically diverse than most of our peers, but we want to stay one of the more economically diverse,” Martin said.
Though the announcement comes on the heels of financial aid changes at Harvard, Yale and Dartmouth, Skorton was careful to differentiate between Cornell and such universities that have recently announced financial aid policies supporting more middle-class students.
“They have smaller student bodies by far and much larger endowments, so it is true that it’s nearly impossible for us to do exactly what a school does that has an endowment five times ours and half the number of students,” he said. “On the other hand, I have to tell you that after being at a public university for 25 years with an endowment that still isn’t even at $1 billion, even though we had the biggest campaign in the history of any non-profit in the state of Iowa, that Cornell is still a resource-rich institution,” Skorton said, in reference to his previously held position as the president University of Iowa.
Martin was also hesitant to propose changes that compare to those of the other Ivy League schools because of the consequences it could have for the way higher education is currently funded.
“I think the way higher education in the United States has been funded over time implies and requires what we could call a three-legged stool, with investments from the state and federal governments, the universities themselves, families and students,” she said. “I really think that higher education ought to be a partnership with investments from all of these parties and that we don’t want to remove the leg of stronger government support for student aid or families and students contributing and being engaged and invested for that reason.”
Cornell’s policy changes also differ in that they involve a 4.9 percent and 5.1 percent increase in tuition for undergraduate students in endowed colleges and out-of-state students in state-supported colleges, respectively.
“Tuition, as a kind of sticker price, it’s only a portion of what it costs to educate any student,” Martin said. “And we believe that those who can afford to pay tuition should pay, and that helps us then discount tuition for students who can’t afford it. So that’s the philosophy that underpins our policies — we’re not reducing tuition, but we do discount it for students and families with need.”
However, graduate students in endowed colleges will see a 10.1 percent cut in tuition to $29,500 in the 2008-2009 academic year and an additional 30 percent decrease in the three years after that. This change will likely improve and expand research at Cornell, which is becoming increasingly important, as Harris noted.
“We’re at a time when research is a huge chunk of the university budget. You’re not seeing NIH (National Institutes of Health) and NSF (National Science Foundation) budgets escalating at the rate we’ve seen in the past, so that means we’re being asked to do more and more as a university. Financial aid is only a piece of that,” Harris said.
According to Martin, the changes require an estimated additional $116.8 million, which will come from a mix of its financial aid resources, an increase in the payout from its endowment, gifts and reallocations of existing resources. A press release states that by the 2008-2009 academic year, the University’s annual financial aid expenditure will increase by $14 million.

Excellent news! I am very
Excellent news! I am very proud of Cornell for finally taking this step.
Go Cornell!
Go Cornell!
Hold on
Personal experience: Those college advertisements are not that true. I took home (after tax, 401k,etc) about $5000/month. My child just received the financial aid package. They ask for family contribution of around $40,000, plus a few thousand of loans (school give $3000 grant, and about $3000 work study).
We simply can not afford $40000/year while still asking the child to bear the burden of the loan, unless we can survive without food, or clothing, or housing for the whole year.
Cornell's new financial aid package
The new Cornell's financial aid package falls short of the packages offered by other Ivy League schools and top university's thoughout the U.S. While other Ivy League schools are offering free tuition for students under $75,000 Cornell is just reducing the loan amounts to $3,000. This does not take into account the family contribution. The family contributions will not change. In many cases the family can not afford what Cornell determines is there responsibility. The following is my personal example:
Family Income: $90,000
Family Contribution determined by Cornell: $19,000
Student Loans: $3,200
My family and I can not afford the family contributions, so either the family, student or both have to take out substantial loans. We do not have all of the $19,000 for the family contribution so we had our child take out the rest in loans and we co-signed. We will definitely help our child when they graduate but there will still be a substantial burden on the family.
It appears that this new financial aid package is a "light" version of what other institutions are doing.
Yeah, you're right...this is
Yeah, you're right...this is a step in the right direction and I'm glad but as a (proud) Cornell grad I'll be in crushing debt for years to come because such a large portion of what they gave me was loans. If I'd gone to Harvard, my $37K would be....nothing.
Family Income:
Family Income: $30,000
EFC:$10,000
Loans before: $12,000 each year!(~48k total!!)
Loans now: 0
I'm happy.
Wow, I'm thrilled for all of
Wow, I'm thrilled for all of you, really. I sure am glad I graduated last year. What else was I going to do with all that money?!
Still not a solution, and the middle class is still clinched.
This is awesome. I'm graduating in 2009 so I get a whole year to benefit from this! Oh wait, no I don't because tuition is being increased by a couple thou and my parents make just over $121,000 a year.
Shouldn't there be some kind of logical, smooth curve that describes how much people's max loan amounts will be depending on their parent's salaries? I guess people like me just get screwed by this ridiculous salary drop-off system.
Oh, and good point made by the parent earlier--I have actually taken out private loans to cover my parents' contribution because they can't afford it.
This is definitely a step in the right direction, but it seems Cornell chose to take only a baby step.
Stingy, stingy Cornell...
#1) This is nowhere near enough. What is wrong with Cornell? Can't they see this sets us behind literally dozens of other universities? Don't they get that we're the cheapest school in the country?
#2) "“Essentially we’ve been thinking about doing this for a long time and the primary reason is because we think that’s too much debt,” she said. According to Martin, these financial aid problems have also long been on President David Skorton’s mind." Utterly disingenuous bullshit from Biddy Martin. What the fuck? STudents had to PUSH the administration to take this little bullshit step. Bullshit you had this in mind. Why didn't you do it last year, then?
#3) What the hell good is this to ppl who will graduate in '08, '09, and those who graduated in '07, '06, '05...? Young graduates are swimming in debt. And what about the upper-middle-class? They get punished for doing well but not being filthy rich?
Cheap, cheap Cornell. Embarrassing.
Very poorly executed distribution of benefits
Maybe I'm a little biased against this plan because I'm a recent graduate and my sister is graduating this spring, but if Cornell really wants to make a difference in students' lives, it should be phasing in a plan to use these new-found funds to help new students by only partially funding their tuition in increasing amounts per year, while helping recent graduates pay off their loans! It's ridiculous to assume that incoming students are the only ones suffering financially, especially with a tough job market and the fact that college tuition has been increasing at a rate several times inflation recently until these new aid programs.
Personally I'm very disgusted with Cornell for writing off its recent graduates' student loan debt, instead of helping them too while phasing in a free tuition program. I LOVED Cornell and swore that all donations I make in the future would be to Cornell and not to my downstate law school. Now, though, this plan is leaving a very bitter taste in my mouth. It would be very, very easy to confirm former students' loans from Cornell that they are currently paying off and their amounts due. Weren't we the ones dedicated enough to come to Cornell even knowing that we would be saddled with student loan debt (though admittedly hoping the job market would be stronger than it is)? Struggling recent graduates should also be able to receive some relief from Cornell's newfound funds, and not have Cornell turn its back on them. Even if it wouldn't help me (most of my loans are now from law school), Cornell would earn its respect back in my eyes.