Opinion

Guilt By Association or A Red Herring

October 15, 2008 - 11:00pm
By Gabriel Dobbs

After an exhausting and masturbatory twenty month long election cycle, thank god the end is finally in sight. Obama and McCain are approaching the last mile of this marathon, and despite a flurry of new attacks and policy proposals, Obama has cleared the hurdles placed before him.

Some discouraging numbers for those who value their constitutional right to shoot wolves from helicopters: Averaging recent polls, Obama is up almost 8 percent nationally (the past two elections have been decided by a margin of less than 3 percent). Recent favorable/unfavorable polls shows Obama is liked by 71 percent of Americans, versus 54 percent for McCain. The eerily accurate Intrade political futres market correctly predicted the outcome of every swing state in the 2004 election (in the face of many polls that predicted a Kerry win on election day). Intrade is now offering a four to one payout for any soul brave enough to put their beans in McCain’s electoral basket. Things look bleak for the Mac Attack, but as they say, it ain’t over til it’s over.

After performing so-so in the past two debates, John McCain was not relying on a slam dunk performance at Hofstra to swing momentum in his favor. But with time running out, there are few avenues left for a Republican victory this November. McCain’s campaign has struggled throughout the primary and general election season to find a unifying message to rally the American people. In an election defined by the change mantra, many Americans aren’t buying the 26 year veteran of the Senate’s pitch that he is a “maverick” here to “shake up Washington.” After all, you can’t teach an old dog new tricks. So what does an old dog do when he’s backed into a corner by the new, hotshot pooch in town? He bites back.

In the final days before Nov. 4, the McCain campaign has made clear with little subtlety that their attacks on Obama will intensify. The recent national spotlight on the economy has led many to the astounding realization that maybe intellectualism isn’t such a bad thing (it might be good to have smart people running our country for a change!). McCain’s long history of deregulation and his connection to the ever unpopular Bush presidency isn’t exactly helping him lay the blame for the economic mess on the junior senator from Illinois. So according to a senior McCain aide, their campaign’s last best shot it to attack Obama’s character: his trustworthiness, honesty, and past associations.

Stage right, enter Bill Ayers: the radical, 1960’s militant anti-war activist. By making the case that Obama is an unknown with a questionable background (he’s black and Hawaiian), John McCain is making a thinly veiled attempt to characterize Obama as a radical, someone who is “not like you and me.” The problem with this last ditch effort to paint Obama as a man who sips martinis with terrorists, is that guilt by association arguments are too often contrived and unconvincing.

Here is an example of a logical fallacy based on an irrelevant association: Hitler was a vegetarian. Hitler was also a Nazi. Therefore, all vegetarians are Nazis. Not convinced that John McCain is using this argument? Bill Ayers is on a charitable board focused on education. Bill Ayers was also a 1960s radical. Because Obama was on that same philanthropic board, he too must be a 1960s radical (despite the fact Obama was eight years old at the height of Ayer’s ‘terrorist’ activities). For the sake of argument, if past associations did matter, it is not difficult to prove that John McCain’s buddies haven’t exactly been saints either.

Right wing televangelist pastor John Hagee was courted early on by the McCain campaign as a man who could help energize the Republican party’s religious base. Shortly after McCain stated that he was honored to have won Mr. Hagee’s endorsement, the media pounced on some of Hagee’s more controversial sermons. Turns out Hagee thought that god sent Katrina to New Orleans to punish the sins of “the gays” (McCain repudiated the endorsement shortly thereafter). But what about the “racist” views of that fiery Reverend Wright? I call your Reverend Wright, and raise you a white supremacist. Richard Quinn, a longtime advisor to John McCain, recently helped the campaign win in crucial South Carolina. (the McCain campaign has paid Quinn’s firm at least $184,000 this cycle). Quinn has his own grab bag of offensive and outrageous positions: he called the MLK holiday “profane and vitriolic,” labeled Nelson Mandela a terrorist, and promoted KKK leader David Duke as a “maverick” (sound familiar?) who should run for the presidency.

As a politician, Obama and McCain have each connected with literally thousands of leaders across the country with personal histories and philosophies across the political spectrum. Why should we hold politicians responsible for every single stupid thing that their acquaintances have done or said? I know people who steal; does that make me a thief, or even someone who promotes stealing? The only friends, acquaintances, or board members whose character should matter in the upcoming election are those who the next president chooses as advisers and members of his cabinet. The Straight Talk Express is stuck in the gutter. The only way for McCain to make any ground before election day is to steer his campaign onto the high road, and focus on the issues at hand.

Gabriel Dobbs is a junior in the College of Arts and Sciences and a contributing columnist for The Sun. Contact him at gvd6@cornell.edu.



Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

While Obama is only ahead a

While Obama is only ahead a few points in the polls Intrade has him with a 60% higher probability of getting into the White House. It's very hard to argue with those odds. In fact if McCAin was to actually win the election I would be far more easily convinced that the election was fixed rather than Intrade had been predicting wrong all along.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.