News

Alleged Assault Incites Controversy

C.U. incident draws attention to rape on college campuses

April 27, 2008 - 11:00pm
By Ben Eisen and Emily Cohn

“Hey ho! These sexist assholes have to go!”

The chants heard on Ho Plaza last Wednesday reverberated throughout campus, within earshot of the University’s administrators tucked behind the walls of Day Hall. The student activist group, Sexual Violence Resistance Network, touted pickets and distributed pamphlets, inciting inflammatory statements such as, “one in four women at Cornell will have experienced rape and/or attempted rape.”

“Our campus is rife with rape culture,” said Marlena Fontes ’10, in front of a few dozen noisy protestors on Ho Plaza. “I tell you this not to bring you down, but to bring you out to fight.”

Since July, the Cornell Police Department has reported six sexual assaults on campus, four of which were classified as rape. Though the Ithaca Police department handled four of the assaults, Kathy Zoner, deputy chief of the CUPD, could only confirm that one had resulted in arrest.

SVRN’s mobilization and the protest that ensued over the last few weeks has attacked President David Skorton, the entire Cornell administration and the University’s crisis management team for their supposed inability to help and respond to rape victims.

The impetus for the protest began three weeks ago with the alleged rape of a sophomore named Alex (named changed for victim’s confidentiality). According to Alex, it was her friendship with a drug dealer formerly in a West Campus fraternity that spurred the incident. While on ecstasy, she believes she was forced to perform oral sex on him, and possibly engage in vaginal intercourse.

The Federal Bureau of Investigation defines rape as, “carnal knowledge of a female forcibly and against her consent.” Since Alex was under the influence of drugs, U.S. law dictates that her claims can be classified as rape.

When Alex’s Spanish professor saw her in class the day after the incident, she had what she described as bruises and scratches on her face, at which point the professor told her to go to Gannett Health Services. After being assessed, Alex claims that the nurse verified she had been sexually assaulted.

“I went to the hospital the next day. My mouth was really fucked up,” Alex said. “Inside my mouth was all swollen and it looked like second degree burns. [It was actually from] forced oral … At first I was just like ‘what happened to me?’”

Alex was called to a meeting with an assistant dean in the College of Arts and Sciences, where she says she was told she “looked like a junkie from the ’70s” and that she needed to seek help.

“I get there and instead of it being just me and her, there’s a bunch of people there,” Alex recounted.

She said that the assistant dean had also been worried that Alex had a potential drug problem because she had done a project on legalizing heroin, and that when she attempted to say who committed the sexual assault, the dean did not seem to care.

The assistant dean was unavailable for comment.

“I told them what happened and they did not take me seriously,” she said.

Alex maintains that she and Alice Green, another assistant dean of students, agreed that her parents would not be involved in the case.

A week after the incident, Alex said that Green came into her off-campus apartment and told her that her parents were waiting to talk to her in her office.

In a letter she wrote to administration members a few days ago, she stated, “I was basically told, ‘if you don’t pack up and leave now, for your safety you cannot come back to Cornell in the fall’ … Why am I the last one to be informed of my parents coming up? That is such an invasion of privacy.”

Alex told The Sun that she made an agreement with Green that if she were to tell her mother anything, it would be that she “got beat up and that’s why [she] had to go home.”

According to Prof. Andrea Parrot, policy analysis and management, chair of the Cornell Advocates for Rape Education, confidentiality plays a crucial role in dealing with rape victims.

“If you are not a minor, we can’t release that kind of information to your family,” Parrot said.

However, Simeon Moss ’73, director of Cornell Press Relations, said that in extreme cases, “it is a policy to contact parents when someone is in danger to oneself or others, and cases that question the student’s continued enrollment in the University.”

He said that it is the Office of the Dean of Students, along with a support team, that decides when to release a student’s case to his or her parents. However, there are no hard and fast rules for when parents must be contacted.

Alex claimed that the University told her it was “best to get the parents involved.”

Currently, according to the Ithaca Police Department, a case is pending in Alex’s name. Though it is not a criminal complaint, there is a second-hand investigation underway. Moss encouraged anyone with information regarding the incident to come forth and help the authorities.

“[The] case is under investigation,” said Officer Don Hoyt of the IPD, adding that when the case was first opened, “the victim refused to cooperate” with authorities. Often times, Hoyt acknowledged, a “victim is scared and upset and refuses to cooperate, but eventually they come around.”

Now at home, Alex claims that the University has changed its decision daily on how to deal with her situation. After writing the letter to the administration, Alex says that Cornell has told her she will be able to go abroad next fall, as she had planned to do before the incident. She currently has a lawyer, but has yet to press charges against the University.

“Cornell is wrongly making this into a ‘drug problem’ and forcing me to get evaluated when the real problem here is that I got sexually assaulted and nothing is being done about it,” Alex stated. “I am being treated like the problem.”

Parrot said that the services Cornell provides to victims of sexual assault depends on what the individual wants to pursue, specifying that the police, Gannett, the judicial administrator and Victims Advocate Nina Cummings are all available to help.

Triggered by the incident, Alex’s friend Kristin Herbeck ’10 began a campus-wide campaign through SVRN in response to Alex’s case, and what she believes to be the University’s sub par response to rape victims. In a statement distributed at the rally, she wrote, “There is no way we will let Cornell get away with this to maintain a system of impunity for sexual violence against women [sic].”

Others stood up at the rally to speak out against what they believe to be an injustice. The protestors’ impassioned voices rang loud last Wednesday, bringing up concerns about Cornell’s response to sexual assault cases on campus. Their remarks uncovered past dissatisfaction with action taken by the Judicial Administrator.

“We are informed [by Cornell] when someone’s iPod is stolen, but we’re not informed when someone is harassed and assaulted,” one protestor lamented. “President Skorton is responsible. This is unacceptable.”

Four years ago, The Sun reported a rape that occurred on Labor Day of 2004 on University property. Relatives of the victim claimed that the Judicial Administrator silenced the case.

However, Parrot emphasized to The Sun yesterday that the J.A. can only prosecute students on sexual assault charges if there is evidence. Often — especially when a victim waits a long time to report the incident — there is insufficient evidence to implicate rape. Furthermore, the J.A. will not press charges if the victim does not want to.

Judicial Administrator Mary-Beth Grant was unavailable for comment.

The larger issue of rape on college campuses has raised much concern over the last few years. Rape charges filed against members of the Duke University Lacrosse Team fell into the national spotlight in 2006, eliciting criticism regarding assault on college campuses.

Today’s university culture, largely described as involving “casual hook-ups,” has also raised concerns about student safety. According to the Brown University Health Education website, 90 percent of campus rapes occur when alcohol is involved.

Though Alex’s case has drawn attention on campus, many more rapes go unreported. The University Rochester’s 1992 Sexual Assault Statistics report that only 16 percent of rapes are reported to the police. This means that about 650,000 rapes actually occurred in 1992.

For now, Alex is waiting for confirmation regarding her academic status at Cornell. Though she claims otherwise, Moss said that Alex is currently a full-time student, and he expects that she will finish the semester.


Related Topics: protest, Sexual assault

evidence?

"While on ecstasy, she believes she was forced to perform oral sex on him (her DRUG DEALER!), and possibly engage in vaginal intercourse."

I'm confused. Reading the rest of the article it then sounds like she did not suspect assault until a later date, AFTER a nurse told her there was some type of burns in her mouth. So, she has zero memory of what went on? She suspected nothing until questions were asked about her appearance and people thought she had a drug problem?!... and then upon examination she began to allege that "she believes she was forced" and "possibly engage" in sexual activity? I'm sorry, assault is clearly wrong, and such criminals should be fully prosecuted... but I have known many people who have done E, never have I heard of such a black out. Additionally, rape is a huge offense and warrants just punishments... but it also warrants credible and sufficient reliable evidence. I don't see that from a case that lacks memory, allegations appeared after other questions against the girl were raised, and the accuser was high on drugs (a drug I'm not even aware of having anywhere near this effect).

How can you think to convict someone of a felony when the accuser was high, has no memory, suspected nothing unusual, and then only raised flags once flags were raised against her? I think the administration seems to have handled this correctly. If there is now reason the girl wants to prosecute, it is on her to bring charges and provide evidence.

For all involved, I hope there is true, convincing and believable evidence. Rape is no joke, it should be treated seriously... by all parties.

No rape at Duke

Is the reporter aware that the charges against the Duke lacrosse players were dropped? The woman who made the complaint has a history of making false charges and the district attorney who pressed the case was disbarred for prosecutorial misconduct.

"no rape at duke"

How ludicrous it is that the Duke case has been hailed by rape-deniers as the end-all of rape cases... just because one highly publicized case was thrown out of court does NOT mean any other rape charge is necessary false. Our culture has a pervasive "blame the victim" mentality, so it is really such a shock that the charges were dropped, if the victim was being harassed and shamed at every turn?

,Also, PLEASE read articles more carefully next time: "Rape charges filed against members of the Duke University Lacrosse Team fell into the national spotlight in 2006, eliciting criticism regarding assault on college campuses."

All that the reporter brings up is the fact that the Duke case brought collegiate rape cases onto the national news scene; there is no editorial slant.

"No rape at duke": shame, shame on you for contributing to a culture that defends so blindly any man (or woman) that is accused of rape, without mentioning the victims at all; the very fact that an article like this would inspire your comment, instead of one of outcry against sexually-based violence, is unfathomable.

Please, let us all keep a

Please, let us all keep a cool head. The shameful aspect of the Duke case is not that there was an investigation, or that the men turned out to be innocent of the charges against them, but because of the exaggeration and hysteria surrounding the publicity of the event. There is such thing as due process, and an immediate public drumhead trial merely confuses and obfuscates any investigation that should occur. (We saw this also with the Jena 6 case) If you or anyone are a witness to this crime, then go to the police or the University. Let's not succumb so quickly to conjecture, rumor, and reactionary outbursts. To the 99.9% of the community that was in no way involved, getting angry at a convoluted, poorly written, and uninformative Daily Sun article is not going to help in any way.

The University is also entirely within its rights to pursue a drug investigation of both the victim and the alleged rapist. Hopefully the University will pursue it with a little more tact than "you look like a junkie," however, the cold, hard truth is that having a terrible thing (and make no bones that rape is always inexcusable) happen to you is not some free pass for criminal behavior.

And I would suggest, Lauren, that you be careful as to who you imply to be a sexist pig. To be sure there are a lot at this school, but your vitriol is not going to help, and it may turn any potential allies against you.

Well, Lauren, as a member of

Well, Lauren, as a member of a jury a couple years ago that convicted a guy of rape and sexual assault, I'd say I've done a lot more to fight sexual violence than you have. When I see Duke casually slandered by journalists, I'm going to comment on it. I hope you're never falsely charged with a heinous crime.

This girl deserves all the

This girl deserves all the help, cooperation, and justice in the world. The person who did this to her deserves to rot in a cell.

THAT BEING SAID it does sound like she has a drug problem, and, just as being a drug addict doesn't excuse her from receiving all the attention, justice, and help from the police, the school and the community, being raped doesn't excuse her from the fact that she is breaking the law and has a serious problem.

drugs

Does the law distinguish between plaintiffs who were forced to be under the influence of drugs and plaintiffs who chose to be under the influence of drugs?

Now I'm not aware of how

Now I'm not aware of how they handled this particular situation....but I was raped last semester, and I can honestly say that I have nothing but positive things to say about how the school handled the situation. They were in constant contact with me, provided me with all the services and counseling you could need, spoke with my professors to get me extensions on assignments since I took a bit of time off, and offered to have someone come with me when I was going to have to identify my assailant in a lineup. As a matter of fact, someone from the school who I had spoken with called me recently just to check and see how I was dealing. I would not have been able to finish the semester and cope with the experience were it not for the amazing support that Cornell gave me, and while it's terrible if they have reacted this way to this girl's allegations, I assure you that this is not how they handle all instances of this kind, and I would be very surprised if this were the University's typical response, as my experience was exactly the opposite.