News

Rhee ’92 Teaches Cornell About Value of Service

October 6, 2009 - 1:48am
By Nikhita Parandekar

Eleven percent of the class of 2009 applied for positions at Teach for America, a non-profit organization in which students teach for two years in underperforming, low-income school districts. Washington, D.C. public schools chancellor Michelle Rhee ’92 gave a lecture last night in a crowded Bailey Hall about the challenges of managing a public school district — and one that was “the most troubled public school district in the country” when she took office in 2007.

According to Rhee, at that point there was a 70-percent gap between the performance of black and white students, only seven percent of ninth graders graduated from college and eight percent of eighth graders were on grade level. Furthermore, kindergartners who entered relatively on par with urban counterparts in other cities were two grade levels behind the same students by the time they were in fourth grade.

Let class begin: Michelle Rhee ’92, Chancellor of Washington, D.C. Public Schools, speaks in Bailey Hall.Let class begin: Michelle Rhee ’92, Chancellor of Washington, D.C. Public Schools, speaks in Bailey Hall.Rhee, a strong advocate for programs such as Teach for America and City Year in which students engage in 10 months of community service in public school systems, was a Teach for America participant herself after Cornell. “Every single kid deserves a right to be educated in an excellent public school so they can be what they want to be, and they can live the life that they dream,” Rhee said. The two programs are unaffiliated but are both funded by AmeriCorps.

According to Rhee, the two main problems she found with the public school system were “a complete and utter lack of accountability” and politics. She went on to say that two things were required to deal with these problems — one being good leadership, and the other being high quality teaching.

In terms of leadership, Rhee spoke to Washington, D.C. Mayor Adrian Fenty’s devotion to improving the public school system. “In his second day in office, he introduced legislation to take over mayoral control of the schools,” she said. “The things we’ve been doing over the last two-and-a-half years are things that drive most politicians crazy.”

For example, Rhee narrated that when she came into office she encountered many people who felt no obligation towards their work and she wanted to remove them from their positions. Current legislation, however, did not allow her to do so. Fenty then worked to introduce legislation to give Rhee power to fire workers she thought were incompetent. According to Rhee, he also refused to cut the budget of DCPS, asking that other departments shoulder more of the burden so that the children did not have to pay for the mistakes of adults.

Radical decisions such as this one have defined the course of Rhee’s term as chancellor, and as expected, they have received their fair share of opposition. The Cornell Organization for Labor Action is one group that disagrees with Rhee. COLA members handed out quarter cards in front of the lecture, saying that they “just wanted to make sure the other side got heard,” according to Andrew Wolf ’10.

“I think she might not have the best interest of the teachers and the actual value of education in D.C. at heart,” Stephanie Knight ’09 said.

Wolf said that COLA wanted to encourage Rhee to work more with the teachers’ unions instead of vilifying them. When COLA members were asked how they decided their position, they said that they spent 20 minutes brainstorming in their last meeting.

Rhee herself acknowledged that many of her decisions have not been popular. For example, there were 140,000 students at the height of the DCPS, but when Rhee took office there were only 50,000 students, yet all of the schools were still open. She closed 23 schools, which is 15 percent of the total in order to bring expenses down and use money more efficiently.

“The factor that I believe has the most impact on the quality of education is the teachers,” Rhee said in explaining her strategy. Rhee said that she would rather see vibrant, motivational teachers in the classroom for two years than mediocre teachers who were around for 20.

“Teach for America has become a really popular thing on campus,” said Ian Hillis, recruitment director for Teach for America at Cornell. Last year Cornell sent the third most graduates into Teach for America out of all the national universities, coming behind only two of the largest universities — the University of Michigan and the University of Texas, Austin, which speaks volumes about Cornellians’ commitment to service, according to Hillis.

Adam Spar ’09, a current City Year corps member, said that he applied for City Year because he wanted to go into Wall Street but recruitment for investment banking in 2008 did not pan out. He became interested in City Year, which he now loves.

“Rhee is so emblematic of what the aims of Teach for America are,” Hillis said. “She used the skills that she gained, the passion that she learned, and went on to make a change in her own way.”

Hills also mentioned that the percentage of applicants last year was up from five percent from the year before, and he stressed that Teach for America is appropriate for students who are interested in any subject area because it instills in students a lifelong mission to decrease the achievement gap, which can be worked at from any angle.

Laura Romeo ’09, a current City Year corps member, agreed. “City Corps is not just for people who want to go into education,” she said. “In order for the public school systems to work, you need to have great doctors, great lawyers, great people working in hospitals or in stores and restaurants — they really foster whatever your interest is.”

“The people who I graduated City Year with went in many different directions,” Romeo said. “It creates a commitment to equity I feel people take into whatever line of work they choose.”

Rhee closed her speech by saying, “Everyone in this room bears a responsibility to change the system. I hope that you will all join in with us in this fight, and as you think about what you’re going to do when you graduate, think about how you can be of public service and make sure that every kid in this country gets the education they deserve.”

Rhee was brought to Cornell by Entrereneurship@Cornell and the Iscol Family Program for Leadership Development in Public Service. Jill Iscol, one of the founders for the program, said that the program’s purpose was to bring the incredibly bright, gifted and talent people who were going into the public service sector to campus in order to illuminate for undergraduates the array of possibilities that are out there for leading a meaningful life.

“Rhee is a woman of courage and conviction, who is unafraid to be the kind of leader who, as she says in her own words, is going to forge ahead because she believes what she is doing is the right thing,” said Iscol. “I think she is a fabulous role model for people who are going to be the next leaders, to think about leadership — that aspect of leadership that requires a certain kind of courage.”


Related Topics: alumnus, public schools

"According to Rhee, [DC Mayor

"According to Rhee, [DC Mayor Fenty] also refused to cut the budget of DCPS, asking that other departments shoulder more of the burden so that the children did not have to pay for the mistakes of adults."

Did Rhee really say that? Are you sure you didn't get that wrong? Because she just pulled off a big Reduction in Force in the schools - a month into the school year - because of supposed budget deficits - which which she hasn't shown any proof of and which the city council denies. (So much for "accountability")

While Rhee was giving her speech in Ithaca, 300 high school students were protesting in front of her office in DC.

Read this Washington Post article to learn more about the RIF and reactions to it

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/10/05/AR200910...

And be sure to read some of the comments to see how people in DC feel about her. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/10/05/AR200910...

From a teacher in Rhee's school system

Here is a comment made in the washington post by a teacher who goes by the name of urbandweller:

" Is it any wonder students don't learn in DCPS? As a DCPS teacher, we are sick and tired of being babysitters, social workers, parents, referees, psychologists, etc. Until we address the social ills these students come to school with, we cannot begin to educate them. All Rhee has done is stir a boiling pot and the pot is about to boil over. Teachers, students, principals and all school-based personnel are on edge. The chaos and stress are worse than I have ever seen in DCPS in my 7 years as a teacher. Great job, Michelle!"

http://voices.washingtonpost.com/dc/2009/10/wild_times_at_woodson.html

Michelle Rhee's statements

"According to Rhee, he also refused to cut the budget of DCPS, asking that other departments shoulder more of the burden so that the children did not have to pay for the mistakes of adults."

As a teacher in the DCPS system it is galling to me that Michelle Rhee said this on the very day that students were protesting the firing of 288 teachers by Ms. Rhee due to a budget cut. A Reduction in Force (RIF)was put into action on Friday, October 2nd with the reason given that the city budget needed to trim 40 million and the school system would have to share in that cut. This firing of 288 teachers happened despite the fact that Ms. Rhee had hired 900 NEW teachers in July. Teachers in our system have yet to receive a satisfactory answer from our Chancellor as to why she hired so many when she and the mayor knew a budget cut was coming. All in all, this statement is in keeping with what we in DC have learned about Michelle Rhee - when it comes to playing the political game she is all politician.

Rhee was my boss for two

Rhee was my boss for two years and I can definitely say that the culture of hostility toward teachers which she developed was the primary reason that I left DCPS. I would not recommend to any person to apply to become a DCPS teacher. Your intelligence, initiative, creativity, and work ethic will be constantly and consistently demeaned by Rhee and her fellow administrators. She is one of the prime stumbling blocks for meaningful improvement in the District.

DC Student protesters against Rhee

Here’s a link to the article in the Washington Post that just came out about the DC students who were protesting about teacher lay-off due to budget cuts in front of Rhee’s office while she was giving a speech on school reform at Cornell last week. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/10/13/AR200910...

Here are some key quotes from the students:

"I'm just confused about why he [Mayor Fenty] hasn't talked about the whole thing," said Doxen, 17, who wants to go to Fordham University. "You always hear stories about how dirty politics is. Now I have some personal experience."

"It just seems like everybody was trying to make themselves look better," said Brittany Timmons, 17, McKinley's student government vice president.

Asked what he learned last week, Ike Umez-Eronini said: "The more you get into power, the less you take responsibility for your actions."

"I'm tired of always being somebody's pawn or guinea pig," he said.

Did Mrs. Rhee highlight her

Did Mrs. Rhee highlight her "Baltimore miracle", where, in her second and third year of teaching alongside a veteran teacher, she brought the students' test scores from the 13th percentile to 90% of the kids scoring at the 90th percentile?

Test scores that can not be found.

Did she mention the positive write-ups she got from the Wall Street Journal, Hartford Courant, and Home Show?

Write-ups that can not be found.

Did she mention she taught for only 3 years but discovered the keys to the universe, (well, kind of) or that the private comapny running the school she taught in was fired the December after she left?

Enquiring minds want to know.