Opinion
The View From Crawford, Tex.
November 6, 2008 - 12:00amThe soon to be former president, reduced to a punch line, an abstraction McCain ducked and Obama abused, slithers back to Crawford in tatters this January. Lost in the dust storm of Obama and his many millions of supporters stampeding toward Washington to reclaim a country they once loved is the departure of the bumbling Texan, our president, George W. Bush.
Finally, the end. Away with the destroyer of freedom and humility and the virtuous America. Be gone, creator of chaos and starvation and shame. The day is here at long last. The king is dead! Rejoice!
I always thought these would be my emotions on the eve of Bush’s exit. A joyous relief, an exhale after years of suffering in bated breath. He was handed an America at the pinnacle of its power and influence, a nation with legitimate potential to make the world a happier, more stable place where the atrocities of the past were confined to the extreme margins. But once America hit his fingertips he fumbled it, sending our nation crashing to the floor, which wouldn’t have been too bad if he didn’t begin frantically stomping on it, rendering it the unrecognizable scramble of limited opportunity and widespread pessimism that we see today.
He did everything wrong. He won the 2000 republican primary by sending out robo-calls suggesting McCain had an illegitimate black daughter. He won the general election because complicated ballots in Florida took hundreds if not thousands votes away from Gore. He failed to recognize pre-9/11 memos warning of an impending attack. He failed to do anything but sit, read and wet his pants when he was told the country was under attack. Failure after failure after failure. Afghanistan. Iraq. The deficient. Guantanamo. Abu Ghraib. Iran. Katrina. Suspension of habeas corpus. Millions of jobs lost. Deregulation. Record oil revenues. Valerie Plame. Axis of Evil. Osama ‘dead or alive’ bin Laden. World economic collapse. Disengagement in Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Blackwater. Decline on the dollar. Decline in American power. Decline in American influence. Decline in quality of life.
The world is a worse place because of George W. Bush. Think of what America has lost because of this man and his cronies. Think about what this man can never give us back. We hate him for it. I was twelve when he came into my life, and now, at 20, I look back and feel robbed of something.
But as a period punctuates the end of Ch. 43: GWB I find my hatred toward him tempered by an involuntary sympathy. Despite legitimate grounds to despise him, I cringe at the tremendous weight of being a complete and utter failure, a weight he will never get out from under. Try to feel the colossal burden he schleps back to Crawford. Not too many people are universally despised. What’s it like going through life knowing that you may very well have brought the greatest nation in the history of world to its knees? Imagine destroying the country you love. How is he supposed to keep on living? Where is happiness found when you know tens of thousands of people are dead because of you? What’s it like on that west Texas ranch?
He’s on his porch surrounded by nothing but the people he loves and a vast expanse of meditative rolling hills that disappear into a setting sun, and everyone trades fragments of funny memories but in the midst of the simple pleasures and “remember when’s” his mind reflects on all that he couldn’t help but destroy. An intense disappointment in self permeates his every action such that nothing and no one offers him refuge. Looking in the mirror before bed he cannot but shake his head and avoid his own eyes in shame.
Or is it something else. Is he something else? Is the post-presidency W. someone far less desolate? Has he not been shattered by the lives he helped end, the legacy he helped squander, and the once burning American promise he helped snuff out? Could he really be evil enough to be joyous in the aftermath of the carnage — holding tea parties at his stately ranch as the ashes of this scorched country crackle around him?
Now in the dining rooms he mumbles a prayer then transitions seamlessness into small talk about farm animals. A hilarious story about a one-legged chicken that tried to stand on a fencepost is recounted to the delight of his guests before the spring pea soup with fernleaf lavender is brought out and the eating commences. Pleasant goodbyes are exchanged and later that night he watches the last ten minutes of Sportscenter before gently kissing his sleeping wife on the forehead and, swelled with distinguishment and pride, comfortably falling asleep himself.
Surely he can’t forgive himself that quickly. I don’t wish the man physical harm, as surely millions do, but I want him to be human enough to be emotionally crushed by what he has done. After all he has ruined he owes it to us to return to Crawford sad and lost and in as terrible a condition as our country is. The thought of the proprietor of the severe American downfall that’s taken place over the last eight years being able to sleep at night disgusts me. It’s not enough that he meant well; he ruined, he ruined and he took lives and for that he shouldn’t be allowed to forgive himself.
So there it is. A somewhat pacifistic kid from suburban Pennsylvania demanding that a former head of state undergo a long and painful depression A country elated, seeing hope in the wresting of power away from this terrible president. A reflection of what he’s done, of the things and people and nation he has broken.
Tony Manfred is a junior in the College of Arts and Sciences. He can be reached at tmanfred@cornellsun.com. The Absurdity Exhibition appears alternate Wednesdays.

The View from Ithaca
I never cease to be amazed at the self-proclaimed wisdom and sense of self-importance of the college editorial staffs who have annointed themselves "guardians of the truth". It was that way many years ago when I was a Cornell student and it hasn't changed much. Tony Manfred's somewhat immature article on George Bush ("The View from Crawford")is proof that arrogance will never be far from a liberal arts major with a pen.
I have never had a problem with dissent. I've always had strong feelings about Presidents myself and will do so until my last breath. But I've always felt that while reporting fact is crucial, the position and those who hold it are worthy of a certain degree of respect. Yes, Presidents do make mistakes. Some of them are big ones. That's part of a big job and there is no bigger than that of President. Bush made them. Clinton made them. So will Obama. But cheap media shots serve no purpose other than to make their author look the fool.
President Bush was a hero after 911 and then made a mistake in invading Iraq in search of weapons of mass destruction. Eventually, he admitted it. He wasn't the only one who was wrong - and while Democrats take glee in saying he lied to them, a more discerning view in the future will show they were just as wrong as he was. Most of those who criticize him on Iraq were in agreement with him when the whole mess started. In fact, Barack Obama was one of the few Democrats who didn't! If you don't believe that, there is plenty of video available with politicians of all sizes and shapes saying the invasion was necessary. Hillary Clinton, Nancy Pelosi, John Kerry and many others agreed with Bush - but didn't have the character to admit it later. Being honest didn't serve them well when being against the war became popular. That wasn't much of a surprise to those of us who have followed politics for years.
Mr. Manfred, I hope that before you graduate and become a member of the media you will somehow remember that the role of the media is to educate the public - not to distort the truth with crass penmanship. Even respected editorialists recognize this. Hopefully one day you will too!
I for one am happy that we have a black President. It was time and I hope he succeeds. But winning doesn't grant him instant credibility. He much earn it. No doubt the media will do everything in it's power to make sure he goes down in history as a great President - but to most of us, he will have to prove his mettle - and we hope he does.
Likewise I am thankful that people like your will have to earn our respect with the quality of your work. You may succeed but until your learn more about honor and respect, I doubt that the odds of success are as good for you and your brand of writing as they are for Barack Obama. Being editor of the "Podunk Times" may not turn out to be the job you envision now.